Sometimes. The useful question is not whether it works, but which part of a working funnel it is able to carry across.
Funnel hacking works for the part of a funnel it can copy, and the part it can copy is rarely the part that made the original work. A funnel's structure, sequence, offer stack and price anchoring are real levers, and copying a well-built structure is better than inventing a poor one. But a funnel's performance is the product of its pages and the people arriving at them. A hack carries the pages across. The people stay where they were.
When you bring a similar audience with similar trust. If the original's visitors and yours arrive knowing about as much, believing about as much and wanting about the same thing, the structure is doing most of the work in both places, and copying it transfers most of the value.
When the purchase is low stakes. In categories where the decision is quick, the price is small and the risk of being wrong is minor, mechanics matter more than relationship. A clean offer and a well-placed upsell can carry a sale on their own.
When the original's edge really was mechanical. Some funnels outperform because of a specific structural decision: a better order of questions, a clearer offer, a smarter guarantee. Those decisions are visible and transferable.
When the original runs on a founder's audience. Many of the funnels most worth hacking belong to people with years of content, a large email list and an audience that already trusts them. Their visitors arrive warm. The funnel's job is to collect a decision that was mostly made before the first page loaded. Rebuild the same pages for a cold visitor and they are being asked to do a job they were never designed for.
When your customers are at a different point in their motion. A funnel tuned for people ready to buy this week will feel pushy to people who are just starting to notice the problem. Same pages, different customer, different result.
A funnel hacker sees the pages and never the numbers. You do not see the original's conversion rate, its advertising cost, its refund rate, how much of its traffic came from an existing list, or how many buyers ever bought again. You also only hack the funnels that look successful, which means you never see the identical ones that quietly failed.
That does not make funnel hacking worthless. It makes it a hypothesis, not a result. The original's success is evidence that its structure can work for its audience. Whether it works for yours is the experiment you still have to run, and the honest way to run it is covered in how to study a competitor funnel.
Look for signs of borrowed warmth before you copy. Does the funnel open with a price, or with a long story? Does it name a founder people already follow? Do its testimonials mention years of content, a podcast, a community? Is most of its promotion going to an existing list rather than to strangers? The more of these you see, the more of the funnel's performance belongs to its audience, and the less of it will travel.